Does FINRA Best Execution Apply to Tokenized Securities?
FINRA best execution for tokenized securities is the Rule 5310 duty to use reasonable diligence to get the most favorable terms for a customer order, applied to tokens traded on ATSs or on-chain venues. Regulatory Notice 26-15 (24 July 2026) says the duty applies however a security is created, and asks whether tokenized-specific guidance is needed.
TL;DR — Key Takeaways
- ✓The baseline: FINRA Regulatory Notice 26-15 (24 July 2026) states that the duty of best execution applies irrespective of how a security is created or the technology it trades and settles on. Rule 5310 already covers tokenized orders.
- ✓The question: Section 9 of the notice asks whether FINRA should provide best execution guidance specific to tokenized securities. Comments closed on 25 September 2026; no tokenized guidance has followed.
- ✓The gap: On-chain venues do not report to the SIPs, AMM prices depend on order size, and costs include gas and failed transactions. A review built on NBBO comparisons does not capture these.
- ✓The split: Bullish wants a tokenized election treated as a directed order; Douro Labs and Securitize say the broker still owns chain, venue and slippage choices. Coinbase and Allium take positions in between.
- ✓The task now: A firm routing tokenized orders needs a documented regular-and-rigorous review that names its on-chain venues, captures order-time pool state and total cost, and records reverted transactions.

What did FINRA ask in Regulatory Notice 26-15?
FINRA asked for comment on modernizing its best execution guidance across nine topic areas, with comments due 25 September 2026. Topic 9, Emerging Technologies, asks one direct question: should FINRA provide best execution guidance specific to tokenized securities?
The notice, published on 24 July 2026, is mostly about equity market structure after the SEC's proposal to remove the trade-through rule. Its nine topics are best execution after Rules 611 and 610(e), access fees and transaction costs, review standards, institutional orders, introducing and receiving firm obligations, extended trading hours, held and not held orders, listed options, and emerging technologies. Tokenization gets a few sentences and one question in the last topic. That paragraph still matters, because it fixes the starting point for every broker-dealer that routes customer orders in a token.
“FINRA notes that best execution is as fundamentally important for investors in tokenized securities as it is for investors in traditional securities, and therefore the fundamental duty of best execution is applicable irrespective of the manner in which the security is created and the technology on which it is traded or settled.”
FINRA Regulatory Notice 26-15, Section D.9 (Emerging Technologies), 24 July 2026
The next sentence concedes that “market differences” may affect how firms meet the duty, “due to the mechanics of how securities are traded or the information available to broker-dealers.” FINRA calls a full treatment of tokenized securities and AI “beyond the scope of this Notice.” As of November 2026 FINRA has published no follow-up guidance on tokenized securities. This page covers the broker-dealer duty; where it sits next to token-level controls such as transfer restrictions is set out in the guide to smart contract compliance versus Layer-0 governance for RWA.
What does Rule 5310 already require for a tokenized order?
Rule 5310 requires reasonable diligence to find the best market so the price to the customer is as favorable as possible under prevailing market conditions. Firms that do not review order by order must run a regular and rigorous review, at least quarterly, by security and order type.
“In any transaction for or with a customer or a customer of another broker-dealer, a member and persons associated with a member shall use reasonable diligence to ascertain the best market for the subject security and buy or sell in such market so that the resultant price to the customer is as favorable as possible under prevailing market conditions.”
FINRA Rule 5310(a)(1), as quoted in Regulatory Notice 26-15
The notice restates the factors that decide whether diligence was reasonable: the character of the market (price, volatility, relative liquidity), the size and type of transaction, the number of markets checked, the accessibility of the quotation, and the terms of the order as communicated. It also lists seven execution-quality considerations for the periodic review: price and price disimprovement, price improvement available elsewhere, likelihood of execution, speed, size, transaction costs, and customer needs and expectations.
Two existing points apply to tokenized trading without any new guidance. A firm “cannot transfer its best execution obligations to another firm”, so routing every token order to one affiliated ATS or one liquidity provider without an independent review of execution quality is a problem today. And the review must compare current routing against quality available at other markets, which means the on-chain venues a token trades on are part of the comparison set whether or not the firm connects to them.
Where does a standard execution review break for on-chain trades?
At the data layer. A typical review compares fills to the NBBO built from SIP data, but SIPs receive no quotes from AMMs or on-chain order books, and AMM prices change with order size. Gas, protocol fees and reverted transactions add costs the review does not record.
The most detailed account of the mismatch is the joint letter from Douro Labs and Securitize Markets, dated 11 August 2026. Douro Labs says it develops on-chain reference-price services, so its proposal that firms may use such prices as benchmarks is also a commercial interest. The structural description is still useful, and the table below maps it onto the review factors. The right-hand column is our analysis, not FINRA's position.
| Review factor | On-chain difference (per comment letters) | What the review would need (our inference) |
|---|---|---|
| Price vs reference | SIPs do not receive AMM or on-chain order book data; no NBBO exists on weekends or holidays | A documented reference price per session, with its source and method stated |
| Accessibility of quotation | An AMM has no resting quote; price is a function of order size and pool depth at execution | A pool-depth or quote snapshot at order time, sized to the actual order |
| Transaction costs | Gas, protocol fees, slippage, pre-funding, bridge fees | Total cost per fill, including gas paid on failed attempts |
| Likelihood of execution | Near-certain if gas and depth suffice; zero if the transaction reverts | Revert and failed-transaction rates by venue |
| Speed | Measured in block times: about 400 milliseconds on Solana, about 12 seconds on Ethereum | Separate timestamps for order, block inclusion and finality |
| Order handling risk | MEV: front-running, sandwich attacks and reordering, but also order-flow auctions and rebates | Record of submission path (public mempool or protected) and slippage limits set |
“This is not simply ambiguity; rather, it is a structural mismatch that leaves broker-dealers without meaningful guidance and investors without the protections Rule 5310 is designed to ensure.”
Douro Labs LLC and Securitize Markets, LLC, comment letter on Regulatory Notice 26-15, 11 August 2026
The letter adds a data point that matters for evidence: there is no consolidated on-chain tape, so the trade data for a regular and rigorous review “must be assembled from blockchain explorers, smart contract event logs, and proprietary order records.” Settlement timing is a second variable. When execution and settlement collapse into one transaction, the price can include the value of removing counterparty risk, which is why the letter warns against reading every price gap between token and share as poor execution. The trade-offs of that design are covered in what atomic settlement changes for liquidity and prefunding.
What did commenters ask FINRA to do about tokenized securities?
Four letters that address tokenized trading in detail agree that Rule 5310 applies and disagree on how far a customer's choice of on-chain execution narrows the broker's duty. The sharpest split is whether that choice counts as a directed order.
| Commenter (date) | Main request | Position on a tokenized election |
|---|---|---|
| Douro Labs and Securitize Markets (11 Aug 2026) | Interpretive guidance under Rule 5310 for on-chain venues: order-specific best market, on-chain reference prices, MEV as a factor, a principles-based safe harbor | Fixes the settlement environment; chain, venue, gas and slippage stay within the broker's diligence |
| Bullish (25 Sep 2026) | Recognize settlement speed, custody, margining and multi-venue integration cost as factors | Should be a directed order under Supplementary Material .08; tokenized ATSs could treat all orders as directed |
| Coinbase (25 Sep 2026) | Confirm that Rule 5310 as written accommodates self-custodied, peer-to-peer execution | A term of the order and a customer expectation; the duty runs to that objective in the chosen environment |
| Allium (25 Sep 2026) | Standardize evidence, not outcomes: traceable, comparable, reconstructable, decision-relevant records | Not framed as a directed order; asks firms to separate customer restrictions from their own access choices |
“When a customer affirmatively instructs a broker to execute an order in a tokenized security format, that instruction should be treated as a directed order under Supplementary Material .08, relieving the broker of any obligation to seek execution at a potentially superior price on a non-tokenized venue.”
Bullish, comment letter on Regulatory Notice 26-15, 25 September 2026
Douro Labs and Securitize address the same question in a footnote and reach a narrower answer. A directed order under .08 names one market, so nothing is left for the broker to decide. An election to trade on-chain names an environment, and the broker still picks the chain, the pool and the submission path. Their letter asks FINRA to say that such an election is “a relevant and potentially dispositive factor as to settlement modality” but does not by itself satisfy Rule 5310 for the remaining variables.
Coinbase argues from agency law that the duty follows the customer's instruction. It cites the SEC's 2022 Order Competition Rule estimate of about 1.08 basis points per dollar traded, which it puts at roughly two dollars on a $20,000 order, to argue that a buy-and-hold customer may rationally value self-custody above that difference. Allium, a blockchain data company, focuses on records, and makes the point most relevant to permissioned tokens:
“These principles also apply to permissioned onchain trading. A visible pool may still require investor eligibility, an authorized wallet, or available funding. Those conditions should be distinguished from restrictions the member could reasonably address.”
Allium Labs, Inc., comment letter on Regulatory Notice 26-15, 25 September 2026
All four are comments, not regulatory positions. The Coinbase letter and the others are posted on the notice page with the rest of the comment file.
How does the SEC Rule 611 rescission proposal change the question?
It would make Rule 5310 the main execution-quality check. The SEC proposed on 11 June 2026, in Release 34-105655, to rescind the Rule 611 trade-through rule and Rule 610(e), stating that a broker's best execution duty would apply regardless. Comments were due 17 August 2026.
The proposing release links the change partly to tokenization. It says distributed ledger technology lets issuers tokenize a security in the format of a crypto asset, and that “smart contract applications undergirding automated market makers” have introduced new methods of trading securities. It also asks what steps the Commission or SROs should take on best execution if Rule 611 goes. FINRA cites that question in Notice 26-15. As of November 2026 the proposal has not been adopted.
The Commission stated that Rule 611 “is not needed as a backstop to best execution given today's highly automated, interconnected and competitive equity markets, where retail investors have widely available access to market data and execution quality information, and a broker's duty to provide best execution would apply regardless.”
SEC Release No. 34-105655, as quoted in FINRA Regulatory Notice 26-15
Douro Labs and Securitize go further. They argue that on-chain executions of tokenized NMS stock likely fall outside Rule 611 already, through the exception for trades not executed on “regular way” terms, because atomic settlement has no standard T+1 clearing terms. That is the commenters' reading, not an SEC or FINRA position. Their conclusion is the same either way: Rule 5310 still applies. Separately, the SEC's order letting Tokenized Securities Venues trade tokenized NMS stock through permissioned AMM pools gives venues exchange-definition relief; Allium notes it does not provide general relief from broker-dealer obligations.
What should a regular and rigorous review include for tokenized orders now?
It should name the tokenized venues in scope, capture order-time price and depth for the actual order size, record total cost including gas and failed attempts, and keep the evidence that ties each fill to the customer instruction. None of this waits for FINRA guidance.
The list below is our inference from Rule 5310, the notice and the comment letters. It is not a FINRA checklist and not legal advice.
- Venue inventory. List every venue where each tokenized security trades, including on-chain pools and ATSs the firm does not connect to, with the reason for each exclusion. Separate customer limits (eligibility, wallet allowlisting, funding) from the firm's own access choices.
- Instrument identity. Confirm the token carries the rights of the security ordered before comparing it with the traditional line. A price-tracking wrapper is not the same instrument.
- Reference price per session. State which benchmark applies in regular hours, overnight and on weekends, and why. Keep the NBBO where it exists; document any other source and its method.
- Order-time snapshot. For AMM routes, record pool state and the expected effective price for the order size, plus the slippage limit sent with the transaction.
- Total cost. Gas, protocol fees, bridge fees and pre-funding cost per fill, including gas paid on transactions that reverted.
- Failure log. Reverted and stranded transactions by venue and cause, reviewed with the same cadence as fills.
- Submission path. Public mempool, private relay or order-flow auction, and the firm's reason for the choice.
- Customer elections. Written record of any election to trade in tokenized form or to self-custody, with the disclosure given, while the directed-order question remains open.
Timestamped, tamper-evident logs of trades and of the compliance checks run on each transfer can support that evidence trail. Blockmaze records compliance checks for tokenized transfers; it is not a broker-dealer, an ATS or a best execution tool, and it does not make the routing decision.
Who is this for, and where does it stop applying?
It is for FINRA member broker-dealers that route or execute customer orders in tokenized securities, including ATS operators. It does not cover issuers selling directly in a primary offering, or market participants that are not FINRA members.
Three limits apply. First, Notice 26-15 is a request for comment; nothing in it changes Rule 5310 or creates a safe harbor. Second, the comment letters quoted here represent the commenters' views and, in several cases, their business models. Third, if FINRA issues tokenized-specific guidance, or the SEC adopts the Rule 611 rescission, parts of this analysis may need revisiting. A firm that has documented its review design will be better placed to adjust than one that has excluded tokenized venues from its review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does FINRA Rule 5310 apply to trades in tokenized securities?
Yes. In Regulatory Notice 26-15 FINRA states that the fundamental duty of best execution applies irrespective of how the security is created and the technology on which it is traded or settled. A member routing a customer order in a tokenized security must use reasonable diligence to find the best market, exactly as for a traditional share. The open question is how, not whether.
Has FINRA issued best execution guidance specific to tokenized securities?
Not as of November 2026. Notice 26-15, published 24 July 2026, only asks whether FINRA should provide such guidance. The comment period closed on 25 September 2026. Until FINRA publishes anything new, firms are held to Rule 5310, its Supplementary Material and existing notices such as Regulatory Notice 15-46, applied to the venues they actually route to.
Is the NBBO a valid benchmark for an on-chain execution?
Not on its own, according to several commenters. Douro Labs and Securitize Markets argue that SIPs receive no data from AMMs or on-chain order books, that no NBBO exists on weekends, and that AMM prices depend on order size. Allium argues the NBBO should remain a common reference, with additional benchmarks only where they are informative. FINRA has not ruled on either view.
Is a customer choice to trade in tokenized form a directed order?
Commenters disagree. Bullish asks FINRA to treat an informed election to trade in tokenized form as a directed order under Supplementary Material .08, relieving the broker of comparing traditional venues. Douro Labs and Securitize say such an election fixes the settlement environment but leaves chain, venue, gas and slippage choices inside the broker's duty. FINRA has not answered.
What does the SEC proposal to rescind Rule 611 have to do with tokenized trading?
The SEC proposed on 11 June 2026 (Release 34-105655) to rescind the Rule 611 trade-through rule, stating that a broker's best execution duty would apply regardless. If adopted, Rule 5310 becomes the main execution-quality check. The release names distributed ledger technology and automated market makers as part of the market change behind the proposal. It is a proposal, not a final rule.
Related Articles
What Will SEC Examiners Check on Tokenization in 2027?
The SEC's fiscal year 2027 examination priorities name tokenization for clearing agency and Regulation SCI exams.
Where Do Tokenized Real-World Assets Trade After Issuance?
SEC-registered ATSs, MiFID II MTFs and digital securities exchanges where security tokens trade after issuance.
What Has to Change Before US Markets Trade 24 Hours?
Overnight trading, clearing and NMS rules in a market that never closes, and where tokenized markets fit.
Does Every Tokenized Stock Clear Through One Pipe?
Most tokenized equity products in scope clear through a single broker, and only a small share of volume settles on-chain.