Legal & Regulatory10 min read
MB
Editorial Team
·November 2, 2026·Updated November 3, 2026

Is Tokenised Gold a Fund Under the FCA's CIS and AIF Rules?

The FCA's tokenised gold Call for Input is a paper published on September 14, 2026 that asks whether gold tokens could improve UK wholesale markets and whether some of them are collective investment schemes (CIS) or alternative investment funds (AIF). The FCA's reading: a token for an allocated, tradeable bar is more likely outside both definitions, while fractional interests in a collectively managed bar indicate pooling. Responses closed on October 23, 2026.

TL;DR — Key Takeaways

  • ✓The paper: The FCA published its tokenised gold Call for Input on September 14, 2026, alongside FS26/1 on wholesale tokenisation. It asked five questions and closed on October 23, 2026. No feedback statement is listed as of November 3, 2026.
  • ✓The perimeter: Direct ownership of an allocated, commercially tradeable bar is more likely outside the CIS and AIF definitions. Fractional interests in a bar managed or disposed of collectively indicate pooling. Co-ownership structures are the open question.
  • ✓The options: Five possible responses, from a good and poor practice note (FCA led) to an eligible gold token classification (Treasury and FCA) and a bespoke regime (all three authorities). None is a firm proposal.
  • ✓The spec: Any alternative regime would need to cover 12 areas, including reconciliation of physical and on-chain records, independent audit, sole-liquidity-provider dealing and orderly wind-down. Our reading: that list is the closest thing to a product specification the UK has published for gold tokens.

Ready to get started?

Join others who are already using our platform.

Is Tokenised Gold a Fund Under the FCA's CIS and AIF Rules?

What did the FCA's tokenised gold Call for Input ask?

It asked five questions about the benefits, risks and regulatory gaps of tokenised gold in UK markets, with one question devoted to whether some gold tokens should sit outside the CIS and AIF regimes. The paper was published on September 14, 2026 and closed on October 23, 2026.

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published the paper on the same day as FS26/1, its feedback statement on the May 2026 joint FCA and Bank of England Call for Input on wholesale tokenisation. FS26/1 reports 123 responses. The gold paper says respondents to that earlier consultation raised gold because of the strength of the London spot gold market, which prompted a more targeted look. FS26/1 also says a joint tokenisation roadmap with the Bank of England will follow later in 2026.

The scope is narrower than the title suggests. Paragraph 2.4 limits the paper and its policy options to products that confer ownership rights in the underlying physical gold and that have transparent, consistently evidenced backing, clearly defined ownership rights and reliable redemption. A token that is only a contractual claim on an issuer is not what the FCA is discussing. Paragraph 2.2 adds that the FCA does not aim to regulate parts of the gold market that are currently outside its perimeter.

The five questions in Chapter 6 cover: where the benefits and risks lie for wholesale and retail use; where interoperability matters most for collateral; whether a defined set of gold tokens should be regulated outside the CIS or AIF regime, and on what conditions; where else regulatory clarity is needed; and how gold tokenisation fits with other industry and regulatory projects. For how gold tokens fit into tokenisation more broadly, see our institutional guide to RWA tokenization.

“This Call for Input has now closed. We'll review all responses and use them to shape our future approach.”

FCA, Call for Input: Tokenised gold, page updated October 26, 2026

Why does CIS or AIF status matter for a gold token?

Because a gold token classed as a fund unit brings authorisation, distribution, disclosure and supervisory duties for the manager, and may be treated differently as collateral than gold itself. The FCA says that even uncertainty about the classification can restrict adoption.

Paragraph 5.2 notes that the CIS definition is broad: a CIS can be dedicated to property of any kind, including assets that are not financial instruments. A gold token is a CIS if it meets the three limbs of the statutory definition. The AIF definition in the UK AIFM regulations overlaps heavily and is framed in EU-law terms, including the idea of a collective investment undertaking. An arrangement is an AIF only if it meets every element of that definition, and an AIF may or may not also be a CIS.

The consequences the paper lists are concrete:

  • No UCITS route: a UCITS scheme cannot be dedicated to gold (para 5.3).
  • Marketing limits: a CIS dedicated to gold may be an unregulated CIS, which limits marketing to consumers and to some classes of investor (para 5.3).
  • Manager duties: fund status can trigger authorisation, distribution, disclosure and supervisory requirements for the firm managing the product (para 5.8).
  • Collateral and capital: prudential treatment and the ability to exchange the token as collateral may differ depending on whether it is classed as gold or as a fund unit (para 5.9).
  • Investor appetite: classification as a CIS or AIF, or doubt about it, may make the token less desirable or less feasible to hold for some investors (para 5.6).

The definition itself is also moving. Paragraph 5.5 records that the FCA consulted on changes to the UK AIFM regime in July 2026, alongside a Treasury consultation that includes proposals to clarify the legislative definition of an AIF, drawing on parts of the FCA's Perimeter Guidance Manual (PERG). Any analysis done today should be re-run once that legislation settles.

“The prudential treatment of a token and the ability to exchange it as collateral may also vary depending on whether it is classified as gold or a fund unit.”

FCA, Tokenised gold Call for Input, para 5.9 (September 2026)

Which gold token structures does the FCA see inside or outside the perimeter?

The FCA describes two ends and one open middle. Direct ownership of a whole allocated bar is more likely outside; fractional interests in a collectively managed bar indicate pooling; fractional co-ownership of an allocated bar is a structure the FCA wants industry to justify.

Paragraphs 5.11 to 5.13 set out the FCA's reading. The table below maps common structures to that reading. The structure labels and the final column are our editorial interpretation of those paragraphs, not FCA determinations, and none of it is legal advice.

StructureFCA's indicated viewOpen question (our reading)
Token represents direct ownership of a whole allocated bar that can be commercially traded“More likely” outside the CIS and AIF definitions: each investor has a direct, allocated interest with no pooling or management of the property as a whole (para 5.11)Whether the issuer still manages anything collectively, such as vault rotation, insurance or bar substitution
Tokens represent direct co-ownership of an identified allocated bar, without identifying each holder's specific shareNot decided. Industry argues certain UK legislation outside financial services allows transfer of undivided shares in goods. The FCA is open to hearing why such structures would not still meet all elements of the definitions (para 5.13)Which limb of each definition the structure fails, and whether the bar is ever managed or sold collectively
Customers hold fractional interests in a single bar that is managed or disposed of collectivelyIndicates pooling of the form the CIS and AIF definitions envisage; the fund framework for safekeeping and investor rights “may be the most appropriate” (para 5.12)Whether the product is run as a regulated fund or redesigned toward allocated ownership
Token is a claim on an account provider for unallocated goldNot analysed in Chapter 5. Paragraph 2.9 describes unallocated gold as a claim on the provider with counterparty exposure, and paragraph 2.4 limits the paper to products conferring ownership rights in physical goldOn our reading this sits outside the paper's scope; its treatment needs separate analysis

The middle row is where most retail-sized gold tokens fall, since few holders can buy a whole bar. Our analysis of a gold token built on co-ownership of allocated vaulted gold shows what this design looks like in a live product, though the FCA paper does not name or assess any product. The burden is on the issuer: paragraph 5.13 asks firms to explain why their structure would not meet every element of the definitions, not why it might fall outside them.

“If customers hold fractional interests in a single gold bar and the bar is managed or disposed of collectively, this would indicate pooling of the form envisaged in the CIS and AIF definitions.”

FCA, Tokenised gold Call for Input, para 5.12 (September 2026)

What are the FCA's five possible policy responses?

Paragraph 4.4 lists five responses, from a practice note led by the FCA to a bespoke regime involving all three UK authorities. The FCA says they are not firm proposals and could be used alone or in combination.

#Possible response (para 4.4)Lead
1Evaluate market developments and publish, for example, a good and poor practice noteFCA
2Clarify how existing rules and supervisory expectations apply, through guidance or other materialsFCA
3Develop a recognised “eligible gold token” classification for specified regulatory purposes, with objective conditions on rights, custody, redemption, governance and technologyTreasury and FCA
4Assess targeted rule changes or focused legislative changes where strong evidence shows unintended or disproportionate outcomesTreasury and FCA
5Consider whether a bespoke regime for tokenised gold, or tokenised commodities more broadly, would be necessary and proportionateFCA, Treasury and Bank of England

Chapter 5 narrows this for the fund perimeter. Paragraph 5.14 names two options: clarity or guidance on the existing perimeter, for example through supervisory communications, and working with the Treasury on a possible targeted exemption from the CIS and AIF perimeter for certain gold tokens or gold market infrastructure. Paragraph 5.16 makes any exemption a matter for the Treasury's discretion. Paragraph 5.8 records that feedback to the earlier wholesale consultation suggested the tokenisation roadmap should include steps to expressly exclude these products from the perimeter.

Paragraph 4.5 adds a constraint that cuts against a broad carve-out: any approach should support competition “without lowering regulatory standards” and avoid conferring credibility on poorly designed products. Paragraph 4.6 says the lessons may also inform work on other commodities.

What would an alternative regime for gold tokens need to cover?

Twelve areas, listed in paragraph 5.15, from the legal nature of holder rights to orderly wind-down on insolvency. The FCA says any wider exemption would be limited to products more appropriately regulated under a different regime with more effective protections.

The framing matters. Paragraph 5.15 says products that are not run as funds and do not present comparable risks may benefit from clarifying exemptions or guidance. A wider exemption is conditioned on a replacement regime, to avoid regulatory arbitrage and the promotion of unregulated funds to the public. The 12 areas are:

  • The legal nature of holders' interests and ownership rights
  • The nature and quality of the underlying gold
  • Custody, vaulting and segregation of the gold
  • Issuance and redemption arrangements, and reconciliation between physical and on-chain records
  • Independent audit and assurance, including of custody records and the reconciliation method
  • Governance and accountability, such as oversight of outsourcing and third parties and of changes to product terms
  • The gold-price benchmark and valuation method
  • Dealing arrangements, including where the issuer or an affiliate is the sole liquidity provider
  • Operational resilience and cyber security
  • Financial crime and market integrity controls
  • Disclosure, especially to retail investors, of risks, custody, redemption rights and fees
  • Orderly wind-down and protection of holders' interests on insolvency

Our reading: if the UK takes the eligible gold token route, these 12 areas are the likeliest starting point for its conditions, so an issuer can treat them as a gap analysis now. Several are already familiar from our guide to compliant gold tokenization, which covers reserve verification and custody attestations. Two are less often addressed. Item 8 targets a common market design in which the issuer is the only source of liquidity. Item 12 asks what holders get if the issuer fails, which is a question about legal title and the custody chain as much as about the token; our overview of institutional RWA custody sets out the custody side.

“Any wider exemption would need to be limited to products that were more appropriately regulated under a different regime providing more effective protections.”

FCA, Tokenised gold Call for Input, para 5.15 (September 2026)

What does the wholesale collateral case for gold tokens depend on?

On legal certainty about holder rights, insolvency treatment, the secured party's ability to control and realise the token, settlement finality, and reconciliation of on-chain records with vault records. The FCA lists all five in paragraph 3.4.

The paper frames the trade-off in today's OTC gold market. Allocated gold gives stronger certainty of ownership because the custodian records specific bars as owned by the account holder, but it is slower and more costly to mobilise as collateral. Unallocated gold moves easily between accounts but is a claim on the account provider, which adds counterparty exposure. The metal and cash legs of an OTC trade also settle through separate systems, creating timing and reconciliation risk (para 2.9).

Tokenisation is pitched as a way to get allocated-style ownership with faster transfer. Paragraph 3.2 lists securities lending, repo and derivatives as collateral uses, and paragraph 3.3 gives delivery versus payment of gold tokens against US dollar tokens as an example. Paragraph 3.5 adds a market condition: collateral use depends on counterparties accepting the same token across many exposures, and without common, mainly market-led standards, liquidity fragments across token models. Whether gold tokens are used as collateral today, rather than traded, is the subject of our analysis of tokenized gold turnover versus collateral use.

The perimeter question feeds straight into this. Under paragraph 5.9, a collateral taker may treat a token differently if it is a fund unit rather than gold, and market infrastructure needs a high degree of certainty. A co-ownership token with an unresolved status is harder to put into a collateral schedule than one with a settled classification.

What should a gold token issuer map before the FCA responds?

Its structure against paragraphs 5.11 to 5.13, its controls against the 12 areas in paragraph 5.15, its retail disclosures against paragraph 3.9, and its cryptoasset status under article 88F. These steps are our recommendations, not FCA requirements.

  • Structure memo: state whether holders own whole allocated bars, co-own identified bars, or hold pooled interests, and record any collective management or disposal of the bars. If you rely on co-ownership, set out which element of each definition the structure fails, as paragraph 5.13 invites.
  • Twelve-area gap analysis: for each item in paragraph 5.15, name the control, the document that proves it and the party that owns it.
  • Reconciliation evidence: show how token supply is reconciled with the custodian's bar records, how often, and who audits the method (items 4 and 5).
  • Retail disclosure: paragraph 3.9 expects products sold to consumers to disclose safekeeping and insurance, whether and how redemption works, regulatory status, fees and minimum thresholds, and outcomes if an issuer, custodian, vault, technology provider or intermediary fails.
  • Cryptoasset check: paragraph 5.17 says that even with a CIS and AIF exemption, firms must consider whether the token is a qualifying cryptoasset under article 88F of the Regulated Activities Order 2001.
  • Watch the AIF definition: track the Treasury's proposed clarification of the AIF definition (para 5.5) and re-run the analysis when it is final.

Some of these controls can be enforced on-chain. A compliance layer such as Blockmaze can restrict who may hold or receive a gold token, apply transfer rules by investor type, and keep an auditable record of each mint, transfer and redemption that a reconciliation can be checked against. Vault records, bar allocation and custody remain with the custodian, and classification is a legal question for the issuer and its counsel; no token design settles it. This article is not legal advice.

Sources: FCA, Call for Input: Tokenised gold – opportunities and risk for UK wholesale markets (first published September 14, 2026; updated October 26, 2026); FCA, Tokenised gold: Opportunities and risks for UK wholesale markets, Call for Input PDF (September 2026); FCA, FS26/1: Tokenisation in wholesale markets (September 14, 2026). Sources checked November 3, 2026; no FCA feedback statement on tokenised gold was listed at that date. The structure table, the reading of the 12 areas as a likely product specification and the issuer checklist are editorial analysis, not FCA statements. Not legal advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did the FCA tokenised gold Call for Input close, and has the FCA responded?

The Call for Input was first published on September 14, 2026 and closed on October 23, 2026. The FCA updated its page on October 26, 2026 to mark it closed and said it will review all responses and use them to shape its future approach. As of November 3, 2026, the page lists no feedback statement, and the FCA has not given a date for one.

Is a gold-backed token a collective investment scheme in the UK?

It depends on the structure. The FCA says a gold token is a CIS if it meets the three limbs of the statutory definition. A token giving direct ownership of an allocated bar that can be commercially traded is more likely outside the CIS and AIF definitions. Fractional interests in a bar that is managed or disposed of collectively indicate pooling of the kind those definitions describe.

What is an eligible gold token?

It is one of five possible FCA responses, not an existing category. The Call for Input describes a recognised eligible gold token classification for specified regulatory purposes, supported by objective conditions on matters such as rights, custody, redemption, governance and technology. The Treasury and the FCA would lead it. The FCA stresses that the five options are not firm proposals.

Can a UCITS fund hold or be dedicated to gold?

Not as a dedicated gold fund. Paragraph 5.3 of the Call for Input states that a UCITS scheme cannot be dedicated to gold. A CIS dedicated to gold may instead be an unregulated collective investment scheme, which limits the ability to market the product to consumers or to certain classes of investor. That marketing limit is one reason classification matters for retail gold tokens.

If the UK exempts gold tokens from the CIS and AIF regimes, are they unregulated?

Not necessarily. Paragraph 5.17 says that even if an exemption is introduced, firms must still look at the specific structure of the token and whether it meets the definition of a qualifying cryptoasset in article 88F of the Regulated Activities Order 2001. A token outside the fund perimeter may still fall inside the cryptoasset perimeter.

Ready to get started?

Join others who are already using our platform.