Compliance9 min read
MB
Editorial Team
·November 19, 2026

Can EU CASPs Still Settle in Non-MiCA Stablecoins?

The ESMA opinion on non-MiCA-compliant stablecoins (ESMA75-113276571-1742, 8 October 2026) tells national authorities that EU crypto-asset service providers should not provide any crypto-asset service, custody and transfer included, for asset-referenced or e-money tokens that do not meet MiCA. Legacy exposures must be remediated no later than three months after publication.

TL;DR — Key Takeaways

  • ✓The rule: Paragraph 12 of ESMA's 8 October 2026 opinion: CASPs should not provide crypto-asset services in relation to ARTs or EMTs that do not comply with MiCA.
  • ✓The scope: Paragraph 21 names all nine CASP services, custody and transfer services included, individually or in combination.
  • ✓No workaround: Paragraph 19: warnings, disclosures and client acknowledgements do not cure the problem.
  • ✓The clock: Paragraph 27: legacy exposures remediated no later than three months after publication, which runs to around 8 January 2027. Until then, only sell-only, conversion, transfer or withdrawal.
  • ✓For tokenized assets: Our reading: if a tokenized fund or bond settles its cash leg through an EU CASP's custody or transfer service in a non-compliant stablecoin, that service is in scope.

Ready to get started?

Join others who are already using our platform.

Can EU CASPs Still Settle in Non-MiCA Stablecoins?

What did ESMA's 8 October 2026 opinion say?

ESMA told national authorities that authorised crypto-asset service providers (CASPs) should stop providing every MiCA service for asset-referenced tokens (ARTs) and e-money tokens (EMTs) that do not meet MiCA. The opinion, ESMA75-113276571-1742, runs to 28 paragraphs over five pages.

The legal basis is Article 29(1)(a) of the ESMA Regulation, which lets ESMA issue opinions to national competent authorities (NCAs) to build consistent supervisory practice. Paragraph 9 says the opinion is “addressed primarily” to NCAs. It was announced in the ESMA press release of 8 October 2026 under the heading of services related to “unauthorised stablecoins”.

Footnote 1 sets the definition. A non-MiCA-compliant ART or EMT is one for which the conditions for a lawful offer to the public or admission to trading in the EU under Title III or Title IV of MiCA, “including any applicable exemptions or transitional arrangements”, are not met. The opinion names no token. Paragraph 7 says it does not change European Commission Q&A 2404, which deals with when a CASP service amounts to an offer to the public.

“ESMA considers that CASPs should not provide crypto-asset services in relation to ARTs or EMTs that are not compliant with the applicable requirements under MiCA (non-MiCA compliant ARTs or EMTs).”

ESMA Opinion ESMA75-113276571-1742, para 12, 8 October 2026

How does the 2026 opinion go further than the January 2025 guidance?

The 17 January 2025 statement addressed “certain” crypto-asset services and set an end-of-Q1 2025 compliance date. The 2026 opinion covers all services and adds a presumption: serving a non-compliant token is presumed to breach the Article 66(1) best-interests duty.

The January 2025 ESMA and Commission guidance asked NCAs to ensure compliance “as soon as possible, and no later than the end of Q1 2025”. Paragraph 4 of the new opinion says further guidance was needed on “additional aspects” of services for these tokens. Three changes stand out.

PointWhat the 2026 opinion saysParagraph
PresumptionRisks from the “absence of the issuer-level safeguards required by MiCA” cannot be managed by the CASP and give rise to a presumption that all MiCA services are incompatible with Article 66(1)13
Offer-to-public analysis not neededThe conclusion does not depend on whether each service is an offer to the public or admission to trading under Articles 16(1) or 48(1)14
Disclosure does not cureWarnings, disclosures and client acknowledgements would not sufficiently address the concerns19

The second row removes a common defence. A custodian could argue that holding a token for a client is not an offer to the public. Under paragraph 14, that argument no longer decides the question. Article 66(1) requires a CASP to act “honestly, fairly and professionally in the best interests of clients”, and paragraph 13 says a CASP serving a non-compliant token “would be considered to knowingly facilitate client exposure” to the missing safeguards.

“ESMA considers that reliance on warnings, disclosures or client acknowledgements would not sufficiently address the concerns identified in this Opinion.”

ESMA Opinion ESMA75-113276571-1742, para 19

Which CASP services fall within the opinion?

All of them. Paragraph 21 lists trading platforms, exchange, execution, reception and transmission of orders, placing, advice, transfer services, custody and portfolio management, “individually or in combination”.

Paragraph 22 adds the control duty: CASPs should implement “technical, contractual and organisational controls” that prevent EU clients “from acquiring or increasing positions” in these tokens. The third column below is our reading of where each service touches a tokenized-asset flow; the opinion does not discuss tokenized securities.

CASP service (para 21)Typical stablecoin activityTokenized-asset touchpoint (analysis)
CustodyHolding client stablecoinsSubscription money held before a fund mints shares; redemption proceeds held before payout
Transfer servicesMoving stablecoins between addresses on behalf of clientsThe payment leg of a delivery-versus-payment (DvP) trade
Exchange (crypto-for-funds or crypto-for-crypto)Converting euro or another token into a stablecoinOn-ramp a fund investor uses to obtain the settlement token
Trading platform, execution, reception and transmissionOrder books and order routing in the stablecoinSecondary trading of a stablecoin used as quote currency
Placing, advice, portfolio managementDistributing or recommending the stablecoin, or holding it in a managed portfolioA managed mandate that parks cash in a stablecoin between tokenized-asset purchases

The opinion regulates the CASP, not the token issuer. Authorisation of ART and EMT issuers stays with the EBA and NCAs under Titles III and IV, as paragraph 10 confirms. Whether a token issued jointly by EU and third-country entities is compliant is a separate issuer-level question, examined in the analysis of multi-issuer stablecoins under MiCA.

When does the remediation deadline expire?

Paragraph 27 asks NCAs to require remediation “as soon as possible and no later than three (3) months following the date of publication”. Counted from 8 October 2026, that is around 8 January 2027; the opinion gives no calendar date.

Law firm summaries, such as Arendt's note of 22 October 2026, also state the deadline in relative terms. National authorities apply the opinion, so a firm should check whether its own NCA has set a date. Until remediation, paragraphs 23, 24 and 27 allow only limited residual services.

  • Allowed: liquidation, conversion, withdrawal, transfer or safekeeping of existing holdings (para 24); sell-only, conversion, transfer or withdrawal functions needed to avoid client detriment (para 27).
  • Not allowed: new acquisitions, promotion, trading, active distribution or continued market availability (para 24).
  • Conditions: time-limited, clearly communicated to clients, risk-based and closely supervised (paras 24 and 27).

This clock is separate from the end of MiCA grandfathering for firms that were not yet authorised. That question, whether the firm may operate at all, is covered in what happened after the MiCA transitional period ended. The October 2026 opinion assumes an authorised CASP and limits what it may do.

“Where NCAs identify remaining legacy exposures, they should require remediation as soon as possible and no later than three (3) months following the date of publication of this Opinion. Any continuation of services should be strictly limited to sell-only, conversion, transfer or withdrawal functionalities necessary to avoid client detriment, and should be time-limited, risk-based and closely supervised.”

ESMA Opinion ESMA75-113276571-1742, para 27

What does it mean for a tokenized fund's stablecoin cash leg?

If an EU CASP provides custody or transfer services for the stablecoin that pays for a tokenized fund or bond, and that stablecoin is not MiCA-compliant, the CASP should stop. This is our analysis; ESMA does not mention tokenized securities.

Tokenized products often settle against the stablecoin with the deepest liquidity. In a subscription, the investor's stablecoin may sit with a CASP custodian until the fund mints shares. In an atomic DvP trade, a CASP may move the payment leg while the security leg moves on the same ledger. The trade-offs of that model are set out in what atomic settlement changes for liquidity. Each point where an EU CASP holds or moves the token for a client is a service listed in paragraph 21.

FlowWho touches the stablecoinWithin the opinion?
Fund subscription via an EU CASP custodianCASP holds the investor's stablecoinYes, custody (para 21)
DvP where an EU CASP sends the payment leg for its clientCASP transfers the stablecoinYes, transfer services (para 21)
Redemption paid in stablecoin into a CASP-held walletCASP receives and holds proceedsYes, custody; increases the client's position (para 22)
Investor self-custodies and pays the issuer directlyNo CASP in the chainNot addressed by the opinion
A MiFID investment firm or DLT market infrastructure settles the cash legNon-CASP entityNot addressed by the opinion

A redemption paid in a non-compliant stablecoin is the case most likely to be missed. It looks like an exit, but paragraph 22 targets controls that stop EU clients from “acquiring or increasing positions”, and a payout into a CASP wallet does that. How stablecoins and reserve assets interact in tokenized structures is covered in how real-world assets back compliant stablecoins.

What should a tokenized-asset platform do before January 2027?

Map every cash-leg touchpoint, confirm each stablecoin's MiCA status against ESMA's interim MiCA register, move subscriptions and redemptions to a compliant token or fiat rail, and record the controls paragraph 22 names.

  • Inventory. List every stablecoin accepted for subscriptions, redemptions, coupon or dividend payments, and DvP settlement.
  • Status per token. Check the issuer against the ESMA interim MiCA register, which ESMA publishes as CSV files and which includes ART and EMT issuers. Record the date checked.
  • Touchpoint map. For each flow, name who holds the stablecoin, under which licence, for which client, and in which jurisdiction.
  • Rail switch. Move new subscriptions and redemptions to a MiCA-compliant stablecoin or a fiat rail before the three-month window closes.
  • Client notice. Tell holders of legacy balances which residual functions remain (sell-only, conversion, transfer, withdrawal) and for how long.
  • Evidence. Keep the technical, contractual and organisational controls in writing, since NCAs are asked to assess each authorised CASP (para 25).

Settlement-asset eligibility can be enforced as a rule in the token contract. An issuer can keep an allowlist of accepted settlement tokens and store the regulatory basis and check date for each entry, so a change in MiCA status becomes a configuration change with an audit trail. The trade-offs of putting such rules in a contract, versus a governed compliance layer, are set out in the guide to smart contract compliance and Layer-0 governance for RWA.

Who does this apply to, and where does it stop?

It applies to MiCA-authorised CASPs serving EU clients, through their NCAs. It does not name any token, and it is silent on MiFID investment firms, DLT market infrastructures, the tokenized security leg and non-EU clients.

The opinion is a supervisory convergence tool under Article 29(1)(a). It does not amend MiCA, and paragraph 10 keeps the EBA's and NCAs' powers over ART and EMT issuers intact. Paragraph 28 says ESMA will monitor how NCAs apply it. We have not checked whether any NCA has issued its own implementing notice, and we make no claim about the MiCA status of any named stablecoin. Facts above come from the opinion text, ESMA's 8 October 2026 press release and ESMA's January 2025 guidance. This is analysis, not legal advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a non-MiCA-compliant stablecoin under the ESMA opinion?

Footnote 1 of the 8 October 2026 opinion defines non-MiCA-compliant ARTs or EMTs as asset-referenced or e-money tokens for which the conditions for a lawful offer to the public or admission to trading in the EU under Title III or Title IV of MiCA, including any applicable exemptions or transitional arrangements, are not met. The opinion does not name any token.

When does the ESMA remediation deadline for non-MiCA stablecoins expire?

Paragraph 27 says national authorities should require remediation of legacy exposures as soon as possible and no later than three months after the opinion was published. The opinion is dated 8 October 2026, so three months runs to around 8 January 2027. The opinion itself gives no calendar date, and national authorities apply it.

Can a CASP keep a non-MiCA stablecoin if the client signs a risk acknowledgement?

No. Paragraph 19 says reliance on warnings, disclosures or client acknowledgements would not sufficiently address ESMA's concerns. ESMA's reasoning is that MiCA's issuer safeguards work together, so clients cannot price their absence from a disclosure. The only answer ESMA accepts is to stop providing services that facilitate access to or continued use of the token.

Does the ESMA opinion cover custody of stablecoins?

Yes. Paragraph 21 lists every CASP service: operating a trading platform, exchange, execution, reception and transmission of orders, placing, advice, transfer services, custody and portfolio management, individually or in combination. During wind-down, paragraph 24 allows safekeeping of existing holdings only, time-limited and under close supervisory scrutiny.

Is the ESMA opinion binding on CASPs?

The opinion is issued to national competent authorities under Article 29(1)(a) of the ESMA Regulation, as a supervisory convergence tool. It does not amend MiCA. Its force comes through national supervisors, who are asked to assess each authorised CASP and require remediation, and through the Article 66(1) duty to act in clients' best interests, which already binds CASPs.

Ready to get started?

Join others who are already using our platform.