What Did 127 Respondents Tell the ECB About Appia?
The Appia consultation report is the Eurosystem's 28 October 2026 summary of 127 responses to its Appia Roadmap, the plan for a European tokenised finance ecosystem anchored in central bank money. Respondents backed that anchor but split on whether it should settle on one network or many, and the ECB states that no design decision has been taken.
TL;DR — Key Takeaways
- ✓The result: 127 respondents backed central bank money as the anchor of tokenised finance. They did not converge on an architecture, and the ECB says no design decision has been taken.
- ✓The split: Many respondents favoured settlement on one network to concentrate liquidity; many others expected a multi-network outcome. The report gives no count for either side.
- ✓The middle path: Many proposed central bank money on a limited number of eligible networks under transparent criteria. Whether the Eurosystem can keep control across several networks is still to be assessed.
- ✓The mix: Technical and data providers sent 30 responses and banks 27. Issuers and investors sent 3 each, so the groups whose tokens will settle on Appia were the least heard.
- ✓The timeline: Stakeholder work starts before end-2026 on three topics, cross-cutting testing follows in 2027, and the Appia blueprint is due by 2028.

What did the Appia consultation ask, and who answered?
The consultation ran from 11 March to 22 April 2026 with 18 open-ended questions in two parts, and drew 127 responses. Part 1 answers are published; Part 2, proposals to contribute to Appia's six building blocks, stays confidential.
Appia is the Eurosystem's strategic initiative for a European tokenised finance ecosystem, published as a roadmap on 11 March 2026. The Eurosystem here means the ECB and the euro-area national central banks, together with Danmarks Nationalbank for this project. Part 1 of the consultation covered high-level principles, the network layer as a shared utility, strategic autonomy, common standards, central bank money settlement on a single or multiple networks, Eurosystem-owned versus shared networks, and market engagement. The ECB keeps the questions and published responses on its Appia consultation page.
| Respondent group (ECB classification) | Responses |
|---|---|
| Technical and data providers | 30 |
| Banks and dealers | 27 |
| Associations and standards initiatives | 13 |
| Private settlement assets and payment infrastructures | 11 |
| Trading platforms | 8 |
| Academia | 7 |
| Other | 7 |
| Consulting | 6 |
| Personal capacity | 6 |
| Post-trade infrastructures and intermediaries | 5 |
| Investors and buy-side | 3 |
| Issuers | 3 |
| Public authorities | 1 |
| Total | 127 |
By geography, 85 respondents (67%) came from the EU, 21 (17%) from non-EU Europe, 14 (11%) from the United States and 7 (5%) from the rest of the world. The largest EU shares came from Germany, Spain, France, Italy and the Netherlands. Of the 127, 103 (81%) submitted several contribution proposals, 11 (9%) submitted one, and 13 (10%) submitted none.
“This report reflects market feedback only. It does not reflect the Eurosystem's views, nor does it express any preference on the design and architecture options for Appia, which remain open.”
Eurosystem report on the public consultation on the Appia Roadmap, section 1, 28 October 2026
Did respondents pick one network or many?
No. The report says respondents did not converge on a single model and instead described a trade-off. It gives no count or percentage for either camp; every side is described as “many” respondents.
The single-network case is about liquidity. One network for central bank money settlement was seen as the most effective way to reduce fragmentation, concentrate liquidity, simplify governance and standardise processes. The cost is concentration: a network that becomes systemically important, the risk of long-term lock-in to one technology or vendor, and weaker incentives to innovate. The multi-network case starts from what exists today: tokenised assets already live on several networks. Respondents in this camp warned that if central bank money is usable on only one network, other settlement assets not anchored in central bank money would serve the rest, which weakens the anchor the Eurosystem wants to keep.
| Option in the report | What respondents saw as the gain | What respondents saw as the cost |
|---|---|---|
| Central bank money on one network | Less fragmentation, concentrated liquidity, simpler governance, one ledger for many assets and services | Concentration, systemic importance, technology or vendor lock-in, weaker incentives to innovate |
| Multi-network ecosystem | More resilient, fits diverse business models, keeps central bank money relevant on emerging networks | Greater interoperability requirements, higher risk of fragmenting liquidity, collateral and compliance |
| Limited number of eligible networks | Reflects today's multi-network reality while the Eurosystem sets eligibility, standards and oversight expectations | Fragmentation remains the main challenge; needs strict criteria, contestability and enforceable interoperability |
A related question, whether the Eurosystem should run its own network or offer its services on market-operated ones, also produced no single preference. Respondents saw merit in both, provided the Eurosystem keeps full control over central bank money. Their bottom line was that ownership matters less than guaranteed central bank control, neutrality and open access.
What would a limited number of eligible networks require?
Strict, transparent eligibility criteria, common standards and interoperability across every eligible network. Many respondents called this a realistic medium-term configuration; several called it a credible long-term target.
The option implies a gate. If central bank money settles on some networks and not others, a network operator, a DLT platform or a market infrastructure will need to show it meets the Eurosystem's criteria. The report does not say what those criteria are, and the ECB has not published any. What respondents did list is the failure mode the criteria would have to prevent: without enforceable interoperability standards and common semantics, a multi-network design “risks becoming a set of silos that fragment liquidity, collateral, identity and compliance.”
The central bank side of the question is still open. The report says the feasibility of central bank money settlement on more than one network, in particular the Eurosystem's ability to retain control over central bank money, is still to be assessed as part of Appia. So none of the three options is ruled in or out.
“Many respondents also proposed an alternative approach: enabling central bank money settlement on a limited number of eligible networks, subject to transparent eligibility criteria and common standards.”
Eurosystem report on the Appia Roadmap consultation, executive summary
Respondents also listed design requirements that apply whatever architecture is chosen: strict separation between network operations and the governance of central bank money; open standards; 24/7/365 availability with deterministic finality; programmability for conditional settlement, atomic delivery-versus-payment and payment-versus-payment; and read-only regulatory access separated from operations.
What belongs in the shared network layer?
Most respondents put ledger management, transaction settlement, identity and access management and security inside the shared network layer. Client-facing and commercial services, such as issuance, custody, wallets and onboarding, were seen as better left outside it.
The longer list of candidate shared functions in section 3.3 of the report also includes regulatory and compliance functions such as reporting, attestations and auditability; standards for tokens, smart contracts and messaging; and interoperability gateways. Most respondents preferred a limited coordination layer connecting users to various services over a monolithic ledger or a vertically integrated platform. Several stressed that the network layer need not be one infrastructure; it could be a set of connected networks under a common framework, which is the multi-network argument in another form.
The reason for keeping commercial services out is neutrality. A shared utility that also sells issuance or custody would compete with its own users. Respondents agreed the assets and services layer should be contestable, but views differed on how contestable the network layer itself should be.
Where does compliance sit in the feedback?
Respondents asked the Eurosystem to clarify how Appia interacts with MiCA, the Central Securities Depository Regulation (CSDR) and the Settlement Finality Directive. Some suggested that proof of compliance be embedded in the tokenised assets themselves, not left to self-certification.
The same theme appears twice more in the report. In the standards section, several respondents saw certification of tokenised assets at the network level, rather than through self-certification, as a potentially major benefit of Appia, and some wanted interoperable identifiers in a cryptographically certified or machine-readable format. Among the areas respondents wanted to work on, the report lists “programmable compliance and sanctions screening” and “identity, credentials and business data management”. The report also records a tension it does not resolve: positions and counterparties must be shielded on a shared ledger, while supervisors, auditors and AML/CFT checks need transactions to be verifiable.
“For example, respondents suggested that proof of compliance should be embedded in the tokenised assets themselves, rather than relying on self-certification.”
Eurosystem report on the Appia Roadmap consultation, section 3.4, p. 11
Read this as one respondent theme, not an ECB requirement. It matters for platform builders because a limited-networks model would turn compliance from an issuer's claim into something a network might have to evidence to be eligible. Token-level rules, where a transfer to an unverified holder fails on-chain, are one way to produce that evidence; the trade-offs between contract-level and protocol-level enforcement are covered in our guide to smart contract compliance versus Layer-0 governance for RWA. The legal half of the request, when an on-chain transfer is final under the Settlement Finality Directive, is the subject of when a tokenized transfer is legally final.
Whose voice is thin in the data?
Issuers and investors. Of 127 respondents, 3 were issuers and 3 were investors or buy-side firms, against 30 technical and data providers and 27 banks and dealers.
Together, issuers and investors made up 6 of 127 responses, under 5%. Technical and data providers alone made up 30, or about 24%. The ECB classified respondents on a best-efforts basis, and many banks issue and invest as well, so the split is a rough guide rather than a census. Still, the firms whose tokens will settle under whatever eligibility rules Appia sets, and the firms that will hold them, sent the fewest answers. The stakeholder call on tokenised securities is the next place for them to be heard.
Strategic autonomy is where respondents were most specific about control. Several wanted European governance of core infrastructures, or at least majority European shareholding and majority European representation in decision-making bodies. Some flagged open-source components whose maintainers, foundations or upgrade governance sit outside European jurisdiction, and suggested European participation in those projects, European-hosted repositories or forks, or European-maintained alternatives. Others thought building on global networks could be enough if lock-in is limited and exit strategies exist. For a platform built on a public or foreign-governed chain, that disagreement could become an eligibility question.
What happens next, and when?
The Eurosystem will launch a call for stakeholders on three priority topics, with market work starting before the end of 2026. Cross-cutting testing follows in 2027, and the Appia blueprint is due by 2028.
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 30 March 2026 | Eurosystem starts accepting tokenised securities as collateral in its credit operations | Cipollone speech; report |
| September 2026 | Appia Contact Group begins work (members announced in August) | Report, section 6.3 |
| 21 September 2026 | Pontes starts settling wholesale tokenised transactions in central bank money | Report; Cipollone speech |
| 28 October 2026 | Consultation report published | ECB news |
| Before end-2026 | Market participants join analytical and practical work; call on three priority topics | Report, section 6.3 |
| Mid-2027 | Pontes operating hours extended significantly | Cipollone speech |
| 11 October 2027 | EU securities markets move to T+1 settlement | Cipollone speech |
| 2027 | More complex, cross-cutting public-private testing | Report, executive summary |
| 2028 | Pontes 24/7/365 availability; Appia blueprint delivered | Cipollone speech; report |
The three priority topics are tokenised deposits and payments, tokenised securities, and shared network governance; the ECB news item frames the last as “shared network governance and standards”. A separate stakeholder group on European market-wide standards is being set up, with a call for nominations “in due course”. The scope of the workstreams and how participants are selected have not been published. The Commission, ESMA and the ECB later opened nominations for a European Tokenisation Standards Group, whose mandate is explained in what the EU tokenisation standards group will standardise. Pontes is the near-term rail in this sequence; how it connects DLT platforms to TARGET Services is explained in how Pontes brings central bank money to tokenised assets.
“By 2028, Appia aims to deliver a blueprint setting out key findings, recommendations and principles.”
Piero Cipollone, “Next-day securities settlement, tokenisation and the transformation of Europe's financial infrastructure”, 29 October 2026
What should platform builders do with this now?
Plan for central bank money access as a requirement and treat the network question as open until the 2028 blueprint. The decision a builder can act on today is which eligibility evidence to produce, not which network will win.
- Who this is for. EU CSDs, DLT platform operators, tokenised deposit issuers and banks that must choose where to build in 2027, and issuers deciding whether to answer the stakeholder call on tokenised securities.
- Who it is not for. Issuers with no euro wholesale settlement need, and anyone looking for a confirmed Appia architecture: there is none yet.
- What to prepare. Evidence for the criteria respondents keep naming: interoperability with existing infrastructure, identity and access controls, auditability with read-only supervisory access, and a governance and exit story for any non-European dependency.
- When this analysis breaks. If the Eurosystem publishes eligibility criteria, picks a single network, or concludes it cannot retain control of central bank money across several networks, the trade-off above stops being open.
One caution on reading the report. The ECB summarised the published Part 1 answers; this article does not attribute any position to a named respondent, and the report does not either.
Sources: ECB, “Strong stakeholder support for Appia roadmap paves way for further market engagement”, 28 October 2026; Eurosystem report on the public consultation on the Appia Roadmap (PDF, 21 pages); Piero Cipollone speech, 29 October 2026; ECB, Eurosystem Appia project consultation page. All checked 6 November 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has the ECB chosen a single network for Appia?
No. The ECB news item of 28 October 2026 says "no decisions have been taken at this stage", and the report states it reflects market feedback only, with design and architecture options left open. The feasibility of settling central bank money on more than one network is still to be assessed. The architecture will be set out in the Appia blueprint, due by 2028.
How many respondents favoured one network versus many?
The report does not say. It uses qualitative terms: "many respondents" saw one network as the best way to cut fragmentation, "many other respondents" expected a multi-network outcome, and "many" proposed a limited number of eligible networks. No vote count or percentage split is published, so any figure attributed to the report is not from the ECB.
Who responded to the Appia consultation?
127 respondents, classified by the ECB on a best-efforts basis. The largest groups were technical and data providers (30) and banks and dealers (27), followed by associations and standards initiatives (13). Issuers and investors each numbered 3, and public authorities 1. By geography, 85 came from the EU, 21 from non-EU Europe, 14 from the United States and 7 from the rest of the world.
What did respondents say about compliance in tokenised assets?
They asked for clarity on how Appia interacts with MiCA, the Central Securities Depository Regulation and the Settlement Finality Directive. Some suggested that proof of compliance be embedded in the tokenised assets themselves rather than relying on self-certification, and several saw network-level certification of tokenised assets as a potentially major benefit. These are respondent views, not ECB requirements.
What are the next steps after the Appia consultation?
The Appia Contact Group began work in September 2026. A stakeholder group on European standards is being set up. The Eurosystem will launch a call for stakeholders on three priority topics: tokenised deposits and payments, tokenised securities and shared network governance, with market work starting before the end of 2026. Cross-cutting testing follows in 2027 and the blueprint by 2028.
Related Articles
Why Is the ECB Putting Its Own Funds Through Pontes?
The ECB plans to invest part of its own funds in tokenised securities settled through Pontes, which turns the rail into a testable production service.
What Is the EU DLT Pilot Regime, and What Changes?
The EU legal sandbox for DLT market infrastructures and what the proposed reform changes for tokenised securities venues.
Can an EU Clearing House Take Tokenised Collateral?
ESMA's call for evidence on tokenised collateral in central clearing, its 30 questions and its 15 January 2027 deadline.
Why Can't Two Banks' Deposit Tokens Talk to Each Other?
Why bank deposit-token networks stay siloed, and what four closed bank consortia show about the interoperability a multi-network model needs.