Legal & Regulatory11 min read
MB
Editorial Team
·November 8, 2026

Why Can't a Dutch Security Be Issued Only as a Token?

Direct tokenisation means a security exists only as a token, with no other register behind it. In a study published on 7 October 2026, the AFM and DNB concluded that this is currently not possible under Dutch law. EU law is not the block: the Securities Giro Transfer Act (Wge) and the Dutch Civil Code are, so Dutch issuers fall back on indirect, hybrid structures with two records.

TL;DR — Key Takeaways

  • ✓The finding: On 7 October 2026 the AFM and DNB concluded that direct tokenisation of securities, where the token is the only form of the security, is currently not possible under Dutch law. Only indirect tokenisation is.
  • ✓Not an EU problem: CSDR allows securities to be issued directly in dematerialised book-entry form and is technology-neutral, so a DLT can be the book-entry record. The block is national property law.
  • ✓The two Dutch laws: The Wge only admits pre-existing securities delivered into a giro or collective deposit, and the Civil Code prescribes acts of delivery (deed plus notification, notarial deed) that an on-chain state change does not clearly meet.
  • ✓Pilot Regime: The DLT Pilot Regime does not change national rules on issuance, holding, delivery, pledging and asset segregation, so it does not fix the Dutch gap.
  • ✓Status: This is an exploratory study by two supervisors, not a bill. They recommend a joint follow-up with two ministries and the market to choose between guidance and amending the Civil Code and the Wge.

Ready to get started?

Join others who are already using our platform.

Why Can't a Dutch Security Be Issued Only as a Token?

What did the AFM and DNB conclude on 7 October 2026?

The two Dutch supervisors concluded that a security cannot currently be issued in a CSD only as a token under Dutch law. Their exploratory study finds that only indirect tokenisation is possible, because the Wge and the Dutch Civil Code (BW) do not provide for direct issuance.

The study, “Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands: Towards a clear and future-proof framework”, was announced by DNB on 7 October 2026 under the Dutch headline “AFM en DNB pleiten voor duidelijk juridisch kader voor tokenisatie” (AFM and DNB call for a clear legal framework for tokenisation). It has four chapters and three annexes, and it is based on literature research and discussions with experts and market participants.

“In practice, this means that direct tokenisation of securities is currently not possible under Dutch law.”

AFM and DNB, Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands, section 3.2, checked November 8, 2026

The finding is narrower than it sounds. The supervisors do not say tokenised securities are illegal, and they do not say the Netherlands is closed to DLT. They say the legally relevant issuance, holding and delivery of a Dutch-law security still has to happen outside the token, so the token can only sit on top of an existing record. Without a legal anchor, they write, market participants “fall back on hybrid models with parallel traditional and DLT-based administrations”, and the efficiency gains of tokenisation are “only partially realised”.

This page covers national property law only. How a tokenised security fits the wider compliance architecture of an issuance is in our guide to smart contract compliance for RWA tokens. It is not legal advice.

What is the difference between direct, indirect and incomplete tokenisation?

The AFM and DNB sort tokenisation into three types by legal status, not by technology: in direct tokenisation the token is the asset, in indirect tokenisation it is a contractual claim on an asset recorded elsewhere, and in a digital twin it carries information only.

The study frames the test this way: what matters is “not whether a token technically exists but what legal status the token represents” and whether the registration is legally relevant to issuance, holding, delivery, pledging, asset segregation and third-party protection. The table summarises section 1.2 and the Annex 1 glossary.

TypeWhat the token isRecords keptPossible under Dutch law today?
Direct tokenisation (digital-native security)The only manifestation of the asset; issued, held and delivered as a tokenOne: the DLT registerNo, for issuance in a CSD under the Wge and BW
Indirect tokenisationA contractual right to an intermediary legal structure; the asset is already registered elsewhereTwo: the existing register and the token registerYes, for example with a DLT as the giro or collective deposit administration
Incomplete tokenisation (digital twin)A digital representation or administrative tool; the holder has no right to the assetTwo, with no contractual link between token and assetYes, but the token carries no legal position

The study gives a digital bond issued directly as a token and held only in a DLT registry as its example of direct tokenisation, and a bond already issued and then put on a DLT as its example of indirect tokenisation. It also flags a risk of the indirect form for investors: the holder “may be unclear about the nature and extent of the rights that the token represents”. Note that the supervisors follow the classification of Lavayssière, so constructions some authors call digital twins with a contractual link count here as indirect tokenisation.

Does EU law block direct tokenisation of securities?

No. The AFM and DNB read CSDR Article 3 as allowing securities to be issued directly in dematerialised book-entry form and as technology-neutral, so a DLT could be the book-entry record. The barrier sits in Dutch law, not in the EU text.

Under CSDR Article 3(1), an EU issuer of securities admitted to trading or traded on a trading venue must have them represented in book-entry form, either by immobilisation or following a direct issue in dematerialised form. Article 3(2) requires trades on a trading venue to be recorded in book-entry form in a CSD by the intended settlement date. The study maps both routes onto its typology: immobilisation of an existing security produces indirect tokenisation, and direct dematerialised issuance on a DLT would be direct tokenisation.

“When it comes to the tokenisation of such securities, the CSDR is technology-neutral. A DLT could therefore be used for the book-entry recording of securities.”

AFM and DNB, Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands, section 3.1, checked November 8, 2026

The study adds a qualification that drives the rest of the analysis: these EU outcomes “cannot be seen in isolation from the relevant national legislation.” For securities not intended for trading, registration with a CSD is optional, but the supervisors still analyse the CSD route because that is where CSDR and the Wge meet. A related EU debate, whether to harmonise the private law of token ownership at all, is covered in our page on the MiCA review consultation on the tokenized asset perimeter. Outside the EU, India took the CSD-style route in its Demat 2.0 pilot, where the depository stays the authoritative record and the DLT ledger is only the form of that record.

Why does the Wge stop direct issuance in a CSD?

The Wge only works with securities that already exist and are then delivered into a giro deposit at Euroclear Nederland or a collective deposit at an intermediary. It has no route for creating a security by crediting it to the CSD, which is what direct tokenisation needs.

The Securities Giro Transfer Act (Wet giraal effectenverkeer, Wge) sets up a tiered system. Investors do not hold rights to specific securities; they hold a share in the community of the relevant deposit, and delivery, asset segregation and third-party protection are tied to entries in that chain. The study accepts that a DLT can serve as the administration of such a deposit. What it cannot do is replace the first step, the separate creation of the security before it enters the deposit.

“Although the CSDR offers the possibility for securities to be issued directly in dematerialised form, a direct issue by crediting to the CSD is not provided for in the Wge, which requires a delivery of pre-existing shares for inclusion in the giro deposit.”

AFM and DNB, Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands, section 3.2, checked November 8, 2026

The gap is old. According to the study, amending the Wge and parts of the BW to allow securities in dematerialised form, in line with CSDR, was considered in the 2016 financial markets legislation (Parliamentary Paper 34198, no. 3). It was not implemented, partly because of a lack of clarity about the added value of dematerialised securities. Indirect tokenisation under the Wge therefore takes two steps: the security is validly created under civil law and delivered to a CSD or intermediary, and then it is included in a giro or collective deposit by entry in the administration, which may be a DLT.

Why is an on-chain transfer not clearly a delivery under the Dutch Civil Code?

Because the BW prescribes specific acts of delivery, such as a deed plus notification to the debtor or a notarial deed, and the legislator has not said that a DLT state change counts as one. The supervisors call the BW technology-neutral but not necessarily system-neutral.

The study lists the requirements outside a book-entry structure:

  • Any transfer of property (Article 3:84 BW): a valid title, power of disposal and delivery, with a specific act of delivery for each type of right.
  • Registered claims and debt instruments (Article 3:94 BW): assignment by a deed intended for that purpose and notification to the debtor may be required.
  • Registered shares in an NV or BV: issue and transfer in principle by notarial deed, plus the company law requirements of Book 2 BW.
  • Bearer claims: physical transfer of the document that represents the right.

“Although the notification to the debtor does not have to follow a prescribed form, the legislator has not explicitly stated that a DLT state change (with notification) qualifies as such a notification.”

AFM and DNB, Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands, section 3.2, checked November 8, 2026

The study is explicit that code does not close this gap: contractual provisions or smart contracts “may support this but do not automatically remove the uncertainty under property law.” In practice, parties use existing acts of delivery, such as an electronic deed, a digital delivery instruction or a contractual link to an off-chain administration. For a token contract, our reading is that a transfer function that executes cleanly on-chain tells you nothing about whether title passed under Dutch law; the off-chain act does.

Does the DLT Pilot Regime change the answer?

No. The AFM and DNB state that the DLT Pilot Regime gives exemptions from parts of MiFID II, MiFIR and CSDR but does not change national rules on issuance, holding, delivery, pledging and asset segregation, so Dutch DLT instruments stay indirect.

The DLT Pilot Regime (Regulation (EU) 2022/858) lets market infrastructures use DLT for trading and settlement of DLT financial instruments under conditions. The study treats it as regulatory room to experiment, not as a property law framework: even inside the Pilot Regime, the BW and the Wge decide the legal status of the registration and the position of the holders. Thresholds and the reform of the regime are outside this page.

“The issuance of DLT instruments under Dutch law is therefore limited to an indirect tokenisation form, with Dutch DLT market infrastructures for direct issuance being required to use the national legal system of other Member States through the CSDR passporting scheme.”

AFM and DNB, Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands, section 3.3, checked November 8, 2026

That last clause is the practical consequence. A Dutch infrastructure that wants native issuance has to use another member state's law, so the choice of governing law and CSD comes before the choice of chain.

How do Luxembourg, France, Germany and the UK handle it?

Each gave DLT registration an explicit legal place, by different techniques. The study compares four jurisdictions in Annex 3 and concludes that technology neutrality alone does not make tokenisation scale.

JurisdictionLegal route (per AFM and DNB)Who is responsible for the register
LuxembourgSuccessive blockchain laws within existing securities law; DLT permitted for issuance, registration and transfer of dematerialised instrumentsFunctional roles, including a control agent, keep issuance and registration consistent
FranceA shared electronic recording system (DEEP) whose registration can, under conditions, equal a traditional account registrationMinimum requirements for integrity, holder identification, continuity and access to statements
GermanyA specific statute for electronic securities (eWpG, introduced in 2021), with a central or DLT-based registerA designated or qualified registrar
United KingdomPrivate law recognition of digital assets as objects of property rights, plus the Digital Securities SandboxNo specific DLT securities register; experimentation in the sandbox

The common lesson, in the study's words, is that scaling requires “an explicit choice of which registration is legally decisive, who is responsible for it and what protection rights holders enjoy.” The study also points to market examples outside the Netherlands, including Clearstream's digital issuance processes under the eWpG. The supervisors warn that without a Dutch legal anchor there is “an increasing risk that Dutch market participants will turn to legal systems that more explicitly facilitate digital securities.”

What fixes do the regulators propose, and is a bill coming?

They propose two routes, targeted modernisation of the BW and the Wge or EU harmonisation such as a 28th Regime, and recommend a joint follow-up process with use cases to choose. No bill exists, and we found no government response as of November 8, 2026.

  • National route: clarify or amend the BW and the Wge so that securities can be issued only in book-entry form and be tokenised, held, delivered and pledged directly, with asset segregation and third-party protection. The study cites the Electronic Bill of Lading Introduction Act (Parliamentary Papers 36 743) as proof that the BW can absorb targeted changes for digital registration.
  • European route: support harmonisation such as the 28th Regime. The supervisors call it “not an obvious solution” on its own, because national property law differs considerably between member states and a weak EU regime could add “an extra legal layer”.
  • Sequencing: in the short term, targeted BW and Wge amendments could precede longer-term EU harmonisation.

The recommendation in chapter 4 is a process, not a draft law: “a timely joint follow-up process by the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Justice and Security, DNB, the AFM and market participants”, in which one or more use cases test whether guidance would be enough or whether the BW and the Wge should be amended, aligned with the DLT Pilot Regime revision, the 28th Regime, CSDR and central bank money settlement work. The DNB announcement repeats that call. Until a ministry acts on it, the legal position described above is the current one.

What does this mean for an issuer using a Dutch hybrid structure?

It means running two records and treating their reconciliation as a control. Under indirect tokenisation the legally decisive position sits in the Wge deposit or the off-chain register, so a token balance that drifts from it is an error in the token, not in the law.

Illustrative example (invented, not a real issuer). A Dutch NV issues a bond, has it included in a collective deposit at an intermediary, and the intermediary keeps the deposit administration on a permissioned ledger. Investors see token balances. If an investor sells and the token moves, but the intermediary has not booked the transfer in the deposit administration, the token register and the legally relevant register disagree. The study's analysis implies the off-chain record decides who holds the bond. The same two-record problem appears in wallet recovery, covered in our page on reconciling the register after an ERC-3643 lost-wallet recovery.

A reconciliation control for this setup checks each holder's position in the token register against the legal register on a fixed schedule, records every break with its cause, and blocks corporate actions such as coupon payments on unreconciled positions. Blockmaze builds that kind of on-chain and off-chain reconciliation and audit trail. It does not make direct tokenisation possible under Dutch law; only a change in the law can.

  • Who this is for: issuers of Dutch-law bonds and shares, Dutch CSDs and intermediaries in the Wge chain, and arrangers deciding on governing law for a native digital bond.
  • Who it is less relevant for: securities governed by another member state's law, and crypto-assets under MiCA, which the study does not address.
  • When this breaks: marketing a Dutch-law token as the security itself; treating a smart contract transfer as the legal delivery; assuming a DLT Pilot Regime licence cures the property law gap; and running a hybrid model with no scheduled reconciliation between the two records.

Sources: AFM and DNB, Tokenisation of securities in the Netherlands (English PDF), Dutch version of the study, DNB news item of 7 October 2026, Regulation (EU) No 909/2014 (CSDR), Regulation (EU) 2022/858 (DLT Pilot Regime). Study and news item checked November 8, 2026. Statutory provisions are cited as described in the study.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is direct tokenisation of securities allowed in the Netherlands?

Not at present. The AFM and DNB study of 7 October 2026 concludes that direct tokenisation of securities is currently not possible under Dutch law. The Wge requires pre-existing securities to be delivered into a giro deposit, and the Civil Code prescribes acts of delivery that an on-chain state change does not clearly satisfy. Only indirect tokenisation is possible.

What is the difference between direct and indirect tokenisation?

In direct tokenisation the token is the only manifestation of the security: it is issued, held and delivered in a DLT register with no separate traditional record. In indirect tokenisation an existing security is already registered elsewhere and the token represents a contractual right through an intermediary structure, so two records must be kept and reconciled.

Does the EU DLT Pilot Regime allow native digital securities under Dutch law?

No. The AFM and DNB say the DLT Pilot Regime grants exemptions from parts of MiFID II, MiFIR and CSDR but does not change national rules on issuance, holding, delivery, pledging and asset segregation. Under Dutch law, DLT instruments are limited to indirect form, and direct issuance would have to use another member state's law through CSDR passporting.

Is there a Dutch bill to allow direct tokenisation?

No bill exists as of November 8, 2026, and we found no published government response to the study. The AFM and DNB recommend a joint follow-up process with the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Justice and Security and market participants, using concrete use cases to decide whether guidance is enough or the Civil Code and the Wge must be amended.

Does CSDR stop a security from being issued on a blockchain?

No. According to the study, CSDR requires securities admitted to trading or traded on a trading venue to be in book-entry form, by immobilisation or direct dematerialised issue, but it is technology-neutral. A DLT can serve as the book-entry record. In the Dutch case the obstacle is national property law, not CSDR.

Ready to get started?

Join others who are already using our platform.